Preterism and Replacement Theology

  One of the most dangerous and subversive doctrines held by adherents of Preterism, is the view that in A.D. 70, at the destruction of Jerusalem by the Roman armies, God’s covenant nation of Israel was superseded by the Christian church.  According to Preterists, Israel is no longer part of the divine plan.  Therefore, notwithstanding the sequence of remakable events witnessed in recent years concerning the revival of Jewish nationalism, we are told not to look for any restoration of the Jewish people, and are even assured that any events tending in that direction are without significance.

  What are the grounds for such assertions?  Is old Satan rearing his head for one final assault upon the Jews?  I am afraid to say, the case appears to be so.  The fascistic tendencies of many Preterists, who secretly espouse a form of Dominion Theology, has impelled them to join hands with unbelievers in an attempt to halt God’s purposes to restore his chosen people to a rightful possession of their land.  Satan knows that his time is running out.  As he sees the fig-tree start to blossom (Matt. 24: 32-33), he realizes that this sign portends his doom, heralding as it does the “end of the age.”  What better way for him to postpone his own confinement in the bottomless pit than to put off the regathering of the Jews?  Seeing this, it ought to be the obligation of every Bible-believing Christian to resist such maneuvering, knowing that the peace of the world hinges ultimately on the revival and restoration of Israel.

  When God made the promise to Abraham to bless him and his seed, he gave him a royal grant of land, bounded on the west by the River of Egypt, and on the east by the Euphrates (Gen. 15: 18).  The land was to extend from Hamath on the north to Kadesh on the south (Ezekiel 48: 1-29).  The tract was promised to Abraham himself, and to his seed.  Historically speaking, however, these promises have never been fulfilled.  Therefore, their fulfillment awaits a future time.  The revival of Jewish nationalism is but one sign which proves that God’s purposes to bless His covenant nation have not fallen to the ground. 

   And yet Preterists claim that these events are without any kind of importance!  This claim is made in the face of unfulfilled prophecies such as the above, which makes it all the more reprehensible.  Was Abraham ever raised from the dead to enjoy any inheritance in the land which God promised Him?  The answer is emphatically, no!  For Stephen, when arraigned before the Sanhredrin, said: “And He gave him none inheritance in it, no, not so much as to set his foot on: yet He promised that He would give it to him for a possession, and to his seed after him, when as yet he had no child” (Acts 7: 5).

  Therefore, unless God made promises which He had no intention of keeping, there is not the slightest warrant for the claim that God’s plan for Israel is over.  As long as the promise made to Abraham remains unfulfilled, Israel remains at the forefront of God’s scheme.  If Christians reject this truth, they do so because they have accepted the faulty and unscriptural notion of Replacement Theology.  Is such a view correct?  Paul intimates that this present dispensation will end with the “breaking off” of the wild olive branches from the good olive tree, and the “grafting back in” of the natural branches (Romans 11: 19-25).  Surely this is not “replacement.”

 When we look around us, we can see the preliminary process already starting to happen. One can daily hear the snapping off of useless branches, as Laodicean Christianity becomes more and more rife. The sad apostasy witnessed by orthodox Christians in recent years–the horrible defection of so many from the “faith delivered to the saints” (Jude 3)– coupled with the revival and re-awakening of Jewish nationalism, is a tell-tale sign that we have reached the “sunteleia,” or consummation of the age. 

  Preterists and their supporters have contributed to the problem by claiming that the original Gospel authorized by Jesus Christ need no longer be preached, but that the church should “apply” Old Testament law to our civil and social institutions, and require a mere formal consent to the tenets of Christianity however adulterated they may have become.  This worthless “salt without savor“ religion is just another form of Gentilism in disguise.   The doctrines of Replacement Theology provide a favorable climate for such ideology, which saps the spiritual life of the church from within.  Are we even aware of this?

  Regardless of the prognostications of post-millennial optimists, who tell us that all is ok, the time has come when we must wake up and see what is cooking.  The fact is, Satan is now busy concocting his final masterpiece of deception: Antichrist, who will come forward as a man of peace, but who, in reality will be the most vicious persecutor of God’s Old Covenant people the world has ever seen.

  What is the duty of Christians at the present time?  Is it not to zealously preach the Gospel to all nations, as we have been commanded by Jesus Christ to do?  And at the same time, is it not necessary to warn others of the falsehoods now being taught by those who cry “peace and safety” even in the midst of catacysmic worldwide upheaval?  The lying falsehood of Preterism ought to stand first and foremost on our list of errors to refute and resist.  We must not succumb to any teaching, however speciously dressed, which claims that God’s purpose to restore Israel is past-fulfillment.  When we hear such doctrines, we must frankly recognize them for what they are: delusions which Satan is using to lull many into slumber, and therefore ensure the damnation of more souls.

  As the world plunges more rapidly down the spiral of end-time fulfillment, we who know the truth must be faithful in sharing our testimony with others.  We must also identify error when we find it.  Recognizing the sinister Satanic connection between Preterism and Replacement Theology will be found helpful in refuting its doctrines, as well as a host of related errors.  Whoever you be, wherever you are, if you are a friend of God you will take your stand against Preterism, and in so doing help to baffle Satan’s plans to stall the second Coming of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.

7 Comments »

  Pastor Clint Zeigler wrote @

I used to think like that, but thanks be to God that He has revealed through His perfect Word that Christ is now ruling the earth (John 12:30; Matt 28:18) and His Church is charged with spreading the knowledge of the glory of God till it covers the earth as the waters cover the sea (Hab 2:14; Num. 14:21; Isa 11:9). The Bible clearly teaches that God has only one people, His Church. There is one tree not two, there is one flock, not two, and only one vine, the source of life, that being Jesus Christ.

Dispensationalism is dying (God’s grace). It is a system full of errors and is easily defeated in true Biblical teaching. If you really want to know how a preterist interpets God’s word, I suggest that you read “Postmillianism an Echatology of Hope” by Keith Mathisen. Perhaps then you will have a proper understanding of God’s Kingdom, His King, and His people.

Clint Zeigler
Pastor, Sovereign Christ Church
Mount Gilead, Ohio

  Brian Simmons wrote @

Mr. Zeigler,

I appreciate your input. However, I heartily disagree with any system of theology which spiritualizes and allegorizes promises which God made to Israel. If you really think that Christ’s kingdom has been realized on earth,. in fulfillment of Matthew 6: 10, I don’t know what to tell you. As long as the nations of the world continue worshipping phalluses and eating babies, I’ll continue look for my Savior’s return.

Peace & Health,

Brian

  Clint Zeigler wrote @

Brian,

You have just displayed the very heart of the error of dispensatioalsim. You look to the world to interpet the Scriptures instead of looking and trusting in what God has promised. This is the same mistake the Israelites made when they would not take the promised land (Num 13,14). Instead of trusting in God and His promise, they looked to the world and seen something different. God was not pleased with them, and He will not be pleased with us if we do not believe in His promises and act upon them. We are not to be hiding and waiting for an escape from this world, but rather boldly taking dominion over the fortresses that oppose Jesus Christ. For the gates (a weapon used for defense not offense) of hell will not prevail against His Church!

Clint Zeigler
Pastor, Sovereign Christ Church

  Brian Simmons wrote @

When Christ said the gates of hell would not prevail, was He talking about the visible church? I sincerely doubt it. If so, why has the church splintered into so many denominations? I think He was referring to the church invisible. There will always be a remnant of true Christians, until the world’s end.

  Andrew wrote @

Dear Brian, I also feel a strong conviction that Replacement theology is evil and hermaneutically untenable. I’ve also come to reject Preterism, Dispensationalism and Sesationism. So please forgive me I can be thick, but if you could clearify this statement “but that the church should “apply” Old Testament law to our civil and social institutions”. I’m assuming this was spoken sarcastically? I love Gd’s laws! Thanx, – the young man-

  Brian Simmons wrote @

Hi Andrew,

Thanks for the input. No, I was not being sarcastic. I was commenting on the THEONOMIC way of salvation. The law doesn’t save anybody. It only condemns. Theonomists would put away the preaching of the Gospel, and instead enforce Old Testament law on our civil and social institutions.

Brian

  Andrew wrote @

Just because one believes in Theonomy, doesn’t automaticly affirms it for salvation? What?!! Unless I’m miss understanding Theonomy. I don’t believe Salvation is even possible by observing the Law, but none the less it is all relevant for today. And yes our laws should ideally be modeled after as closely as possible. Sir, if I understand you correctly, you are unintentionally affirming a form of Replacement theology. You are aware that the early church was comprised of Jewish(in Israel) believers and gentile both living by different standards. -young brother-


Your comment

HTML-Tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>